. I can finish Malyn's work, the way we had meant to before his madness. Covering The Best In Video Games, Esports, Movies and Geek Culture I just did this quest again with my evil Argonian, took the Black star and then soul-trapped Aranea in it. For more information, please see our You can head there right at the beginning of the game, too, although youll struggle to complete the quest on higher difficulties without some decent stats and gear. The difference is the Star's use afterwards. The mod is now compatible with patch 1.5 which tweaked marriage rules. Ilinaltas Deluge is no different from the Deep. Pissing off Azura seems like a bad idea RP wise. If your character is a good type, helping Azura would be the better choice because the Star is pur, In general terms, Azura's Star is definitely the one Daedric Artifact worth keeping. These sources tend to be plentiful and easier to kill, compared with common grand level white soul sources, such as mammoths. Azura's Star lets you capture animal souls but you also get a follower. No, everything is quite all right. If youre not prepared for this quest, the enemies will kill you in literally seconds, from range. Speaking with him reveals that there exists a soul gem which can be reused: Azura's Star. Objective. If you bring it to Azura, you will be able to use it to trap any size soul except for black souls (i.e., souls from NPCs). If you take it to him, soul trapping bandits gives you a grand soul. Also, the amount of creatures you can actually get grand souls from are very small - I believe it's giants, mammoths, dragons (maybe? The most precious of them is of course the Broken Azura's Star, lying in front of the throne (screen above). Its very easy to get overwhelmed here, so dont be afraid to try multiple different approaches. When the Star is placed upon the alter of Azura, she tells you that without Malyn Varen's soul being purged from the star, it is utterly useless. So, if you dont mind not being Azuras Champion, then Nelacar is the better option. If you bring it to Nelacar, you will be able to trap all souls, including black, though Nelacar tells you that it can only trap black souls (see bugs section). The difference is the Star's use afterwards. For the Black Star, a refillable black soul gem, take the star to Nelacar, where he will place the Dragonborn inside the star where Malyn will have to be defeated. It is highly recommended that you do not give this artifact to Martin for the Blood of the Daedra quest. For the item, see The Black Star (item). Speak with Nelacar. I wouldnt lose sleep (or significant game progress) as a result of your choice soul gems are reasonably common, even black ones, so Azuras Star is not particularly essential in either form. Nelacar is a former instructor at the College of Winterhold. Enchant, travel back to the cities and sell my stuff; keep the stuff I made for me. The reverse could also be said as well. During your earlier conversation with Nelacar, he will have told you about how all the Daedra are evil and how Azuras Star drove Malyn insane. Doing either gives you Azuras Star but Nelacars one is a bit better but it's kind of corrupted. Additionally, Azura will set Aranea free and she may become a follower. However, I do not know which one is the good and which is the bad ending for the quest. What is the best thing to do with Azura's Star. Is it suspicious or odd to stand by the gate of a GA airport watching the planes? Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Find Azura's Star. After acquiring the broken Azuras Star, the Dragonborn can bring it to either Aranea Ienith or Nelacar, both of whom will task them with evicting Malyn Varens soul from the artifact. These souls can be used for enchanting or recharging. For Grand souls go Giant and mammoth hunting. While giving the Star to Nelacar does not provide a companion option, the Black Star has the advantage of a much more abundant source of grand souls, as all black souls are of the grand level. With regular Soul Gems, you only get one use before the gem breaks. Maybe this is my chance to make things right. All we really know about it is that its the artifact of the Daedric Prince Azura and that it returns to Azura in Oblivion every few hundred years or so. Eventually, the quest will take you to Ilinalta's Deep, a partially-flooded and ruined former Imperial fort. In Oblivion the Black Soul Gems are the Equivenent of the Black Azuras Star and therefore Hold Human Souls. It cannot hold Non-Player Character (NPC) souls; Black Soul Gems are necessary for that. She can be found at the Shrine of Azura, on top of the tallest mountain slightly south of Winterhold, and becomes available for marriage / follower when you complete Azuras quest. As Ive just said, that means you lose out on access to Black Souls. Is there a reason you're asking me?" However, for roleplay purposes, this does mean youll be Azuras Champion. Inside, youre going to have to fight a bunch of Conjurers and Necromancers. After leaving college, he has returned to this out of the way place, the reason being that he still has research to do, and that being close to his former colleagues is convenient. Press J to jump to the feed. Regardless of who you bring the Broken Star back to, youll be transported inside the star to confront Malyn Varen. So unless you really want that follower, I'd suggest going for the Black Star. Keep your eyes open as you make your way through the Deep. Like regular soul gems, Azuras Star has the ability to trap white souls, or those of creatures. . Weapons with Soul Trap enchantments, such as Umbra, are particularly useful when carrying Azura's Star. Function. Very little is known about Azuras Star, including its origin and creation. Money stops becoming a huge issue and you can simply buy more from vendors. Should I bring Azura's Star to Nelacar? If you bring it to Azura, you will be able to use it to trap any sized soul except for black souls (i.e., souls from NPCs). This place is filled with powerful necromancers. I always go with Azura for the same reasons others have said. You found it. We've done it. depends on what type of character you're playing or if you are being good or evil or even rping for that matter but imo it doesn't really matter, grand soul gems are easy to get >.> but if you're playing a mage getting the black soul gem would be good for enchanting purposes because all black souls are grand and white is usually only gotten by rpers playing good characters. As a consolation prize, however, you will get access to Aranea as a follower. Now, anyone that knows their lore will realize that Azura is actually one of the three good Daedra and used to be worshipped as such by the Dunmer, with many of them still revering her as a goddess. For Azuras Star, a refillable grand soul gem, take the Star to Aranea Ienith, forcing the Dragonborn to enter the star by Azura and enter into combat with Malyn after a short dialogue. Azura's Star. The Black star is the most useful of the two given how many bandits we have in this game, but later on Soul gems start dropping like rain so its not really needed. Why is the black star filled with a human soul so expensive? Who do I bring the black star to? Answer: Ultimately, the choice depends on your approach to playing Skyrim. Aranea will send you off to Winterhold in search of an elven mage capable of working on Azuras Star, which as of right now isnt in any working state. Should I bring the Azura's Star to aranea or Nelacar? Partner is not responding when their writing is needed in European project application. In Oblivion the Black Soul Gems are the Equivenent of the Black Azuras Star and therefore Hold Human Souls. Is she worth foregoing the Black Star? Youll then be rewarded with your star of choice depending on who you gave the Broken Star to, and The Black Star quest will complete. If you bring it to Azura, you will be able to use it to trap any sized soul except for black souls (i.e., souls from NPCs). That would be quite unfortunate for my research.". What is the best way to level up in oblivion? A limit involving the quotient of two sums, ERROR: CREATE MATERIALIZED VIEW WITH DATA cannot be executed from a function, What does this means in this context? Once you finish the quest with him, youll get the Broken Star back as The Black Star. He will ask you to bring him Azura's Star, a powerful soul gem which will not be destroyed upon usage and can be refilled an unlimited . The easiest way to reach it is to travel to Winterhold and make your way south-southeast to the shrine. Why Do Cross Country Runners Have Skinny Legs? Interestingly, if one goes for The Black Star then we dont get the option to have Aranea Ienith as a follower. Who is Nelacar Skyrim? Either of these will point you towards a High Elf named Nelacar that is currently living in the Frozen Hearth Inn. For the more practical people out there, youll want to bring the star back to Nelacar. Dervenin is a Bosmer servant of the Daedric Prince Sheogorath, who refers to him as luggage.. Given that its the location of Azuras Star, this means you cant just head there directly before speaking to Aranea of Nelacar. . Might as well take the one that can capture human souls too after that fight. Despite the fact that its one of the most useful items in Skyrim, its got a distinct lack of backstory or lore. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. This version of the star is capable of capturing Black Souls. In terms of powergaming it'd be take the Black Star every time. All rights reserved. Could have had a nice little quest line but nope nothing, not even a line from her. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. At first glance The Black Star sounds much better as there are a lot of humans, like bandits, available to full it with. Your quest marker will lead to a female Dunmer named Aranea Lenith right on the Shrine of Azura. Best answer If you return to Aranea, you get Azura's Star which is like a permanent grand soul gem and you get Aranea as a follower if you return star to Nelacar, you get the Black Star which can trap black souls I would say, if you are into enchanting then go with Nelacar, otherwise go with Aranea for more info, see here: [1] 3 Talk to Aranea Ienith. Nelacar gives you the Black Star which can contain both white and black souls, whereas Aranea gives you Azura's star that can only contain white souls, but she becomes available as a powerful follower. For the Black Star, a refillable black soul gem, take the star to Nelacar, where he will place the Dragonborn inside the star where Malyn will have to be defeated. Honestly, The Black Star is probably the better of the two items, because NPCs are probably more common enemies, and they all give Black Souls, the equivalent of only the most powerful creature souls. Question: Should I bring Azura's Star to Azura or Nelacar? Espaol - Latinoamrica (Spanish - Latin America). These sources tend to be plentiful and easier to kill, compared with common grand level white soul sources, such as mammoths. Function. Copyright 2023 Scrolls Guided | An Avid Interactive Media Company | Powered by Astra WordPress Theme. While giving the Star to Nelacar does not provide a companion option, the Black Star has the advantage of a much more abundant source of grand souls, as all black souls are of the grand level. Azura's Star or The Black Star? Dagur: "This, this is why people have a problem with your college, Nelacar. Azura's Star accepts all other souls, with their varying levels. Alternatively, you can head to the Inn first and speak to the innkeeper. Well, it effectively acts as an infinite Grand Soul Gem. it The Black Star that can only capture black souls i.e human souls Answer: Objectively, The Black Star is better than Azuras Star. Its one of the rare unique items that I actually use rather than lock up in my trophy room, and thats really saying something. First Option: Bring the Star to Aranea If you choose to bring the Star to Aranea, go back to the Shrine of Azura. The innkeeper Dagur and his wife, Haran, tolerate Nelacar and his experiments, in contrast to most of the citizens of Winterhold who generally distrust mages - most notably Jarl Korir, who frequently complains about Dagur letting mages stay at his inn and others from the college (such as Enthir and Arniel Gane) go to the inn at night to drink. As a high-ranking Companion, Aela was a competent warrior long before the Dragonborn came blundering through Jorrvaskr. Just don't strain yourself. For the Oblivion Walker achievement, it doesnt matter who you bring the star back to. The Black Star is Better as Black/Human Souls are More Powerful than Normal White Souls Such as Animals etc.. The Black Star of Azura is a powerful Daedric artifact that works just the same as any Black Soul Gem found in Skyrim with one important difference: it stays intact after use. If the Dragonborn brings Azuras Star to Aranea, however, Nelacar stops offering merchant services and instead berates them for serving Azura if spoken to. It's been a long while since I started this quest so I remember nothing about the 2 choices. Shes pretty competent in combat, so that might be a deal-maker for you. Azuras Star Interior. He can be found at The Frozen Hearth where he runs a small shop. These souls can be used for enchanting or recharging. If you give it to Aranea , she can become a follower. Speak with Nelacar in Winterhold. If you bring it to Nelacar, you will be able to trap all souls, including black, though Nelacar tells you that it can only trap black souls (see bugs section). ", Nelacar: "I'm sorry, could you describe the smell?" Talk to him about the mark and he will say I have no idea what youre talking about. Azuras Star only traps white souls. The Star has been cut off from Azura, and Malyn's soul finally has some measure of peace, even if it is in non-existence. I'd get 20-30 grand gems in one rotation. The game has loads of soul gems, no problems recharging anything ever. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Nov 20, 2011. Privacy Policy. No, once youve finished this quest theres no in-game method of converting the star from one form to another. 360 NX Even if the Speech skill is boosted to over 100 (via jewelry and/or potions), the persuasion option will not work to convince Nelacar to talk about the Star. Either way, youll be presented with a choice here. . If a persuasion attempt on him failed during The Black Star, he will make a reference to the book, If the College's main questline is completed before talking to Nelacar, he will refer to the Dragonborn as ". (Are there other type of black souls?). I don't like the idea of helping a man sympathetic to a wizard who would use his own students' lives to try and achieve immortality. Once you get him to open up, Nelcar will tell you that his former master, Malyn Varen, was experimenting with Azuras Star. He's not sympathetic at all with what that guy was doing. However, its counterpart The Black Star is capable of trapping Black Souls, while Azuras Star cannot. Nelacar: "Oh yes, quite fine. Neither of them are necessarily good or bad. He is one of just three spouses that can actually live on Solstheim with you, as spouses and children cannot move into Severin Manor. Talk to him about the mark and he will say I have no idea what youre talking about. Bolli can usually be found wandering in the market or working in Riften Fishery. Tell Azura you're ready to enter the Star. But she is a daedra. Nelacar: "It was a minor miscalculation. Depends on the character. Speak to Nelacar. Did any DOS compatibility layers exist for any UNIX-like systems before DOS started to become outmoded? Which is better Azura's Star or the Black Star? The Frozen Hearth is the inn in Winterhold. Azuras Star is capable of doing the same, except it can Trap any souls BUT Black ones, so if it cant be trapped by the Black Star, Azuras Star can hold it. Oblivion Walker achievement; The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim After that, it's really just a matter of personal preference which artifact you're willing to part with. I'll be back later. Which Teeth Are Normally Considered Anodontia? Bolli can usually be found wandering in the market or working in Riften Fishery. Can you marry Nelacar in Skyrim? And is this something I'll need to worry about in the future?" He was asked to leave the college due to some failed experiments. However, I do not know which one is the good and which is the bad ending for the quest. Home | About | Contact | Copyright | Report Content | Privacy | Cookie Policy | Terms & Conditions | Sitemap. Take it to Nelecar or whatever his name is. *Disclosure: Some of the links above are affiliate links, meaning, at no additional cost to you, Fandom will earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Yes, it sounds suspicious, but the Dragonborn is perhaps the most naive person ever to grace the land of Tamriel.